Remove Filters


  • 12,200 Indianapolis Listings
  • 1,108 Reduced Listings
  • 1,108 New Listings
Refine your search to less than 500 properties to save.
Delete This Search
Back to Results
Prev Next

1886 Rhettsbury Street, Carmel, IN

$1,777,000 - 4 Beds 6 Baths 8,334 Sqft .2 Acres

Stunning Beaux Arts-style mansion in a premier location in the heart of the Village of West Clay. The intricate classical columns and ornate trim work showcase this architectural achievement. Grand entry way leads through to the stunning formal dining room which features curved string course molding and stunning hardwoods. Gourmet Kitchen with high-end appliances and adjoining breakfast room. Spacious and regal balconies offer stunning views and plenty of private space. Penthouse master retreat with all the amenities. Lower level features theater room, exercise room, wet bar and more.

Listing Status: Active

Thinking of Selling?
Get your free home valuation here.
What's It Worth?

Essential Information

  • BLC® # 21604347
  • Price $1,777,000
  • Bedrooms 4
  • Bathrooms 6.00
  • Full Baths 4
  • Half Baths 2
  • Square Footage 8,334
  • Acres 0.20
  • Year Built 2007
  • Type Residential
  • Style Historic
  • Status Active

Community Information

  • Address 1886 Rhettsbury Street
  • Area Hamilton - Clay
  • City Carmel
  • County Hamilton
  • State IN
  • Zip Code 46032


  • Utilities GasConn
  • Garages Attached


  • Interior Features FoyerLarge, FormalLvRm
  • Heating ForcedAir
  • Cooling CentrlElec
  • Fireplace Yes
  • # of Fireplaces 2
  • Fireplaces FamilyRm, GasLog, Other
  • Stories 2 1/2 Levels


HrdwdFloor, WalkInClos, WdWkPaintd


GrbgDispsl, RefBltIn, CookTopGas, OvenDouble, Dishwasher, Microwave


  • Exterior Brick
  • Lot Description Sidewalks
  • Construction Completed
  • Foundation BsmtPrCnc

School Information

  • District Carmel Clay Schools

Additional Information

  • Date Listed October 26th, 2018
  • Days on Market 333

Listing Details

  • Office RE/MAX Ability Plus

Price Change History for 1886 Rhettsbury Street, Carmel, IN (BLC® #21604347)

Date Details Change
Price Reduced from $1,799,000 to $1,777,000 $22,000 (1.22%)
Price Reduced from $1,995,000 to $1,799,000 $196,000 (9.82%)
Price Reduced from $2,250,000 to $1,995,000 $255,000 (11.33%)
Price Reduced from $2,350,000 to $2,250,000 $100,000 (4.26%)

Similar Listings Properties for Sale Similar to 1886 Rhettsbury Street, Carmel, IN


10810 Crooked Stick Lane, Carmel

4 Beds, 5 Baths, 6,271 SqFt
There are only a few on Crooked Stick Golf Course that ever become available but none like this quality built Dan Elliott Home sitting on over an acre lot midway down the 12th fairway. Home features main floor master suite, gourmet kitchen, vaulted and beamed ceilings in the family and living rooms, formal dining, library with built ins, finished basement with wine cellar, family room, exercise room, golf practice area, screen back porch with
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

1833 Milford Street, Carmel

6 Beds, 7 Baths, 8,044 SqFt
Stunning, Premier Grand Estate located in the beautiful Village of WestClay. Grand Entry open to 2nd Floor. Office with coffered ceiling & wainscoting. Gourmet Kitchen w/center island, stainless steel appliances, plenty of storage & eat-in area opens to 2 story Great Room with fireplace and floor to ceiling windows. Master Suite with double tray ceiling & 2 way fireplace shared with Spa-Like Master Bathroom. Lower Level with rec
RE/MAX Ability Plus

2377 Finchley Road, Carmel

8 Beds, 9 Baths, 9,385 SqFt
Grand, Luxurious Living Fit for Royalty in this Stunning Estate located in the Village of WestClay. Gorgeous features throughout including hardwood floors, wainscoting, beautiful trim, tray ceilings & arched openings. Chef’s Dream Kitchen with 2 islands, stainless steel appliances, hood vent & lots of cabinet space open to grand 2 story Great Room w/ coffered ceiling, fireplace & built-ins. Master Suite on main level w/ sitting
RE/MAX Ability Plus

1616 W 116th Street, Carmel

5 Beds, 4 Baths, 9,443 SqFt
Amazing estate sprawling across 10+ acres along the most luxurious corridor of homes in Indiana. Live among the elite in this 9,000+ square foot ranch home in Carmel. Open the gates to your private drive which runs along a creek, rolling hills, mature trees, and all the privacy you could want while being just minutes from Downtown Carmel and Crooked Stick Golf Course. Upon reaching the end of your driveway you will find a beautiful vintage
RE/MAX Legends Group

All information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties that a consumer may be interested in purchasing. All Information believed to be reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2019 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®. All rights reserved.

Listing information last updated on September 23rd, 2019 at 10:24am PDT.