Remove Filters


  • 12,726 Indianapolis Listings
  • 1,005 Reduced Listings
  • 1,055 New Listings
Refine your search to less than 500 properties to save.
Delete This Search
Back to Results
Prev Next

5420 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN

$689,000 - 4 Beds 6 Baths 4,544 Sqft .19 Acres

Your wait is over for that beautiful storybook home in Meridian Kessler! Desirable New Jersey St. location. All the charm of a 1929 built home you expect with some ideal updating added. Gorgeous kitchen update w/ commercial range/oven, stainless appliances, counter seating, vegetable sink, & skylights. Beautiful wood floors on main & 2nd level (some were added so both levels were all wood) Spacious master w/ 2 closets, 2 sinks, separate tub & shower. 4 full bedrooms on 2nd floor. Incredible 3rd story bonus room w/ new carpet, gas fireplace, & built-ins. Finished basement w/ guest room, full bath, & half bath. Incredible fenced backyard w/ outdoor kitchen with all the accoutrements included. Brick patio, pergola, 2 car garage w/ storage.

Listing Status: Active

Thinking of Selling?
Get your free home valuation here.
What's It Worth?

Essential Information

  • BLC® # 21643470
  • Price $689,000
  • Bedrooms 4
  • Bathrooms 6.00
  • Full Baths 3
  • Half Baths 3
  • Square Footage 4,544
  • Acres 0.19
  • Year Built 1929
  • Type Residential
  • Style Colonial
  • Status Active

Community Information

  • Address 5420 N New Jersey Street
  • Area Marion - Washington
  • Subdivision AMBLESIDE
  • City Indianapolis
  • County Marion
  • State IN
  • Zip Code 46220


  • Utilities HighSpdAvl, GasConn
  • Parking GarDrOpenr
  • Garages Detatched


  • Interior Features FoyerLarge, LndryInBsmt
  • Heating ForcedAir
  • Fireplace Yes
  • # of Fireplaces 2
  • Stories 3 Levels


HrdwdFloor, B/InBkShlv, Skylights, WinWood, WdWkPaintd


Dishwasher, GrbgDispsl, RangeHdFan, Refrigratr, Microwave, O/RGas


CentrlElec, CeilPadFan, WallUnit(s)


GasLog, LivingRoom, MasonryFP, WoodBurn


  • Exterior Wood
  • Lot Description Sidewalks, TreeMature
  • Foundation Basement-Block

Exterior Features

DrvConcret, FenceFullR, Playset

School Information

  • District Indianapolis Public Schools

Additional Information

  • Date Listed May 30th, 2019
  • Days on Market 119

Listing Details

  • Office F.C. Tucker Company

Price Change History for 5420 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN (BLC® #21643470)

Date Details Change
Price Reduced from $725,000 to $689,000 $36,000 (4.97%)
Price Reduced from $765,000 to $725,000 $40,000 (5.23%)
Price Reduced from $795,000 to $765,000 $30,000 (3.77%)

Similar Listings Properties for Sale Similar to 5420 N New Jersey Street, Indianapolis, IN


7020 N Delaware Street, Indianapolis

3 Beds, 4 Baths, 2,704 SqFt
Mid-Century design melds w/pure luxury | Nestled up-the-hill in Arden on the loveliest, manicured parcel | Original details pay homage to the past, while a pristine transformation readies this home for today’s living | Incredible entertaining spaces unfold from the gracious entry | Fabulous gallery walls for gracing your collection | Expansive windows blur the lines of indoor + outdoor | Sophisticated Valcucine kitchen opens to family rm w/stone
Encore Sotheby's International

6455 Dover Road, Indianapolis

4 Beds, 4 Baths, 3,406 SqFt
Renovated Dutch Colonial boasts an array of original details and contemporary upgrades that makes this home feel new again! Nestled on over half acre yard, the portico entrance sets the stage for this bright home which features formal LR w/FP and open concept kitchen/dining area and main floor MBR w/ensuite bathroom. Kitchen features new cabinets, lighting, ss appliances, subway tiled backsplash ss farmhouse sink and peninsula with bar seating.
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

5305 Fall Creek Road, Indianapolis

4 Beds, 4 Baths, 5,587 SqFt
Knockout Lake Kesslerwood views @ lake amenities from this sharp 2006 built home! Relax & enjoy lake front living from the new boat dock (2018) or the 45 ft wide deck, w hot tub, off your kitchen & main level Master! The great floor plan offers a two story Great Rm and Foyer, sharp molding, numerous large windows & open floor plan. A spacious gourmet kitchen, w Granite, Stainless Steel, Gas Cooktop, wine cooler and a separate bar
F.C. Tucker Company

512 E 57th Street, Indianapolis

4 Beds, 4 Baths, 2,860 SqFt
Come and see this Charming Farmhouse that has been lovingly restored to its former beautiful self. Enjoy comforts of modern living while basking in the glow of historic architecture. Original brick hearth, stair parts, trim and hardwood floors guide the path to the remodeled kitchen and family room. Second level master suite includes luxury bath w/free-standing tub and walk-in closet. Third level of this surprisingly large home has two
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

All information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties that a consumer may be interested in purchasing. All Information believed to be reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2019 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®. All rights reserved.

Listing information last updated on October 20th, 2019 at 8:09pm PDT.