Remove Filters


  • 12,835 Indianapolis Listings
  • 1,100 Reduced Listings
  • 1,056 New Listings
Refine your search to less than 500 properties to save.
Delete This Search
Back to Results
Prev Next

1591 Preston Trail, Carmel, IN

$1,100,000 - 5 Beds 5 Baths 6,077 Sqft 2 Acres

Elegant, well-built home on one of the best lots (2 acres) in Crooked Stick. Grand entry gives way to expansive view of private, wooded backyard & paver patio. Phenomenal, open floor plan w/exceptional flow for today's family lifestyle. Extraordinary 12' ceilings throughout. Distinguished wood paneled den with coffered ceilings and lovely fireplace. Open stairs to magnificent lower level featuring a passive wine cellar, open family room with pool table, game table, 5th bedroom and full bath. Back staircase to upper level features 3 enormous bedrooms, each with direct access to bath. This home transcends time and provides a discerning buyer with the perfect opportunity to personalize moving forward.

Listing Status: Active

Thinking of Selling?
Get your free home valuation here.
What's It Worth?

Essential Information

  • BLC® # 21668474
  • Price $1,100,000
  • Bedrooms 5
  • Bathrooms 5.00
  • Full Baths 4
  • Half Baths 1
  • Square Footage 6,077
  • Acres 2.00
  • Year Built 1987
  • Type Residential
  • Style TradAmer
  • Status Active

Community Information

  • Address 1591 Preston Trail
  • Area Hamilton - Clay
  • Subdivision CROOKED STICK
  • City Carmel
  • County Hamilton
  • State IN
  • Zip Code 46032


  • Parking GarDrOpenr, LoadSide
  • Garages Attached


CableConn, GasConn, HighSpdAvl, MunSwrAvl


  • Fireplace Yes
  • # of Fireplaces 3
  • Stories 2 Levels


CeilRaised, ScrnsCompt, WetBar, WinWood, AtcPlDnStr, HrdwdFloor

Interior Features

LndryRmMn, DblSinksMn, FoyerLarge, FormalLvRm, Jk&JilBath, UtilityRm


CookTopGas, Dishwasher, GrbgDispsl, KitExhaust, Microwave, Refrigratr, TrashComp


ForcedAir, High Efficiency (90%+ AFUE ), ElecAirFil


CentrlElec, High Efficiency (SEER 16 +)


FamilyRm, 2SidedFP, Den/Library, MasonryFP


  • Exterior Brick, Cedar
  • Foundation CrawlPrCnc, BsmtPrCnc

Exterior Features

DrvAsphalt, WtrFtr/Fntn, OutBld/Utl, SprnklrSys

Lot Description

StormSewer, StrtLights, Wooded, Pond

School Information

  • District Carmel Clay Schools

Additional Information

  • Date Listed September 20th, 2019
  • Days on Market 32

Listing Details

  • Office F.C. Tucker Company

Price Change History for 1591 Preston Trail, Carmel, IN (BLC® #21668474)

Date Details Change
Price Reduced from $1,195,000 to $1,100,000 $95,000 (7.95%)
Price Reduced from $1,295,000 to $1,195,000 $100,000 (7.72%)

Similar Listings Properties for Sale Similar to 1591 Preston Trail, Carmel, IN


10633 Winterwood Drive, Carmel

4 Beds, 6 Baths, 5,790 SqFt
Exceptional! Resting on a stunning 1.52 acre wooded lot within the heart of the highly desirable neighborhood of Winterwood. A rare offering is now available. Remodeled with thought and attention to detail, 10633 Winterwood Drive offers the following: Impressive master suite complete with custom tile shower, claw foot soaking tub, dual vanity with marble counter tops and spacious walk-in closet. Remarkable great room with soaring cathedral
F.C. Tucker Company

1921 E 116 Street, Carmel

3 Beds, 2 Baths, 1,657 SqFt
Very convenience location, 3 bed, 2 bath, (2018)new carpet and flooring, freshly painted throughout! Sale of two lots, 1921 E and 1917 E 116th St(Lot 32 and Lot 33) total of 1.03 Acres. Property tax $3,118(both lot #32 & 33),Total of 1.03 Acres
Keller Williams Indy Metro NE

1791 Blythe Street, Carmel

5 Beds, 5 Baths, 7,359 SqFt
Gorgeous Craftsman Style Home with modern touches throughout & Stunning Outdoor Retreat Oasis. Open floor plan ideal for entertaining w/ high end custom finishes including hardwood floors, wainscoting, tray & coffered ceilings, plantation shutters & built-ins. LUXURIOUS 1ST FLR OWNERS SUITE w/private retreat, bar & spa-like master bath. Chef’s Dream Kitchen w/oversized center island, Stainless Steel appliances & plenty of
RE/MAX Ability Plus

3380 Shelborne Woods Parkway, Carmel

4 Beds, 5 Baths, 6,058 SqFt
Fabulous New Pulte Located in the prestigious Woods at Shelborne community. Totally decked out Truman model now being sold! Absolutely Top Notch Interior - Dream Home Total Package. Features include 2 story dining room, magnificent Owner’s Suite with sitting room and large walk-in closet, kids’ rooms with loft, stylish office space, coffered ceilings in hearth room and dining room, exquisite woodwork throughout, wonderful finished basement, 3
CENTURY 21 Rasmussen Company

All information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties that a consumer may be interested in purchasing. All Information believed to be reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2019 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®. All rights reserved.

Listing information last updated on October 22nd, 2019 at 7:09am PDT.